No Crying in the Pines: How Archie Gianunzio Designed a Fire Island House for Joy

Peacock wallpaper, a hand-painted kitchen wall and a sign nobody obeys: inside 625 Shore Walk in Fire Island Pines, to book direct on Locèlle.

Modern cedar house with a turquoise pool at 625 Shore Walk, Fire Island Pines

For twenty years, Archie Gianunzio worked in advertising sales, by his own account with “no creative anything at all.” The creative work happened on the side. He became a pastry chef, ran a catering business with a friend, and was the person everyone called when they moved. Would he come and look? Would he suggest something? He loved wallpaper, and no one was paying him for it yet.

That changed at the end of January 2020, when he lost his job. He had a year of severance and nowhere to travel. What he did have, as of the month before, was a house on Shore Walk in Fire Island Pines.

A Quarter Share, Then a House

Archie met his husband, Wesley Bonner, in 2012. Archie had been to the Pines before; Wesley never had. The next summer they took a quarter share, the old New York arrangement of one week a month from May to September, and kept it up for about five years.

They did it their own way. Rather than pool money with a rotating group, Archie took the share himself and filled the beds with friends, many of whom came back every week of the summer. Those weeks were the start of the couple’s habit of hosting.

The house came out of a different search. Around 2018 the couple were looking for an apartment in Manhattan, and the numbers would not work for the kind of place they wanted. Then someone asked why they didn’t buy a house on Fire Island and let it pay for itself. Archie had never even looked.

“If I can’t afford an apartment in Manhattan, how am I going to afford a beach house?” — Archie Gianunzio

He looked anyway, and found four-bedroom houses that, in his words, needed some love. The Pines was still a bit of a wild west then. Many houses had stayed with the same owners for thirty or forty years, and property lines did not always match the paperwork. The couple signed on the house on Shore Walk and then waited. They expected to own it by the summer of 2019, and they didn’t, but having given up their share, they spent that summer in the house anyway. Archie used it to get to know the place and to plan.

They finally closed in December 2019. The house was falling apart, and it had long been rented in quarter shares. The couple wanted something different: to rent it by the week to groups who would commit to it as their one week of the summer, cover the mortgage and costs, and stop paying for summers in someone else’s house.

Rebuilding the Shell

Archie went out to the island in March 2020 and began, though not with the wallpaper. For most of the first two years, the work was on the house itself. All of the decking came up and was replaced. So did all of the siding, every window and every door.

The rebuilt exterior and pool deck of 625 Shore Walk in Fire Island Pines
New siding, windows, doors and decking, all replaced in the first two years.

The heart of the house is its center. You walk in to a staircase in the middle, a catwalk runs around the upper floor to the bedrooms, and the house is open all the way to the roof under a skylight thirteen feet square. When the couple bought it, the skylight was cracked. Its replacement had to cross the bay on the ferry and then travel down the island’s narrow paths to the house. When it came off the boat, the contractors texted a photo, and Archie decided he had seen enough.

“I don’t want to see another thing till it’s in.” — Archie Gianunzio

The front and back walls were a hodgepodge. Windows sat in odd places, and on the second floor a sliding glass door opened onto nothing, put there as the easiest way to get air through a house that had no air conditioning. The couple had both walls rebuilt. For the back, Archie had a model in mind: a house he had walked past with windows so big he hadn’t known they were possible. The contractor said it would be a pain but could be done. The back wall is now four large panes of glass.

“It’s really dramatic architecturally.” — Archie Gianunzio

Open living room with wood beams and a wall of windows at 625 Shore Walk, Fire Island Pines

The house itself is Pines mid-century modern, angular and modeled on the work of Horace Gifford, though newer than the houses Gifford built there in the 1950s and 1960s. In Archie’s telling, Gifford’s clients in the city were not asking for bold ideas, but buyers on Fire Island told him to go ahead.

“We really got revolutionary architecture out there at a time when we were being persecuted everywhere else.” — Archie Gianunzio

Wallpaper, Paint and a Week on a Step Stool

The kitchen wall Archie Gianunzio hand-painted in a Happy Socks pattern, beside the breakfast bar at 625 Shore Walk
The kitchen wall, painted by hand over a week on a step stool.

Inside, Archie gave every bedroom a loose theme. The first was the Peacock Room, for a friend obsessed with the birds, with a second peacock paper hidden inside the closet. The Miami Room came from rolls of mural wallpaper, giant pink and orange palm leaves, that Wesley brought home from a giveaway table at a media office. The Garden Room pairs florals with portraits of women the couple love, including Big Edie and Little Edie of Grey Gardens and Frida Kahlo in a crown of flowers. In the Jungle Room, every woman in the photographs wears animal print. None of it is meant to shout.

The Peacock Room, a king bedroom with teal peacock-pattern wallpaper

“If you notice it, great. If you don’t, it still looks great.” — Archie Gianunzio

The Miami Room, with a pink palm-leaf mural and a red wall

The bathrooms get the same treatment: one is wrapped in red and blue snake print, another in mint and pink palms.

Bathroom wrapped in red and blue snake-print wallpaper at 625 Shore Walk
Bathroom with mint and pink palm wallpaper and a double vanity at 625 Shore Walk
Even the bathrooms are wallpapered, in snake print and mint and pink palms.

The kitchen wall took the longest. Archie copied the pattern and colors of a pair of Happy Socks, a holdover from his years of wearing loud socks with a suit. Wesley’s first answer was the one he usually gives to Archie’s design ideas: no, you’re not. Archie did it anyway, on a step stool, with a foam brush, because the wall is built from siding boards and tape could not hold a clean edge. It took a week. Years later, people seeing it for the first time ask whether it was just painted.

Dining table with white chairs and framed prints beside the painted kitchen wall

Behind it all was a budget. Getting anything to the house means getting it to the ferry, across the bay and up from the dock, which can double its cost. So Archie thrift shopped and refurbished, aiming for rooms that look anything but cheap and stand up to a summer of renters.

The Rules of a Room

All his life, friends have told Archie some version of the same thing: they love being in his home because it is beautiful, but they are not afraid to sit down. It feels like someone lives there. That became the brief for Shore Walk, and for everything he has designed since.

“It doesn’t have to cost a ton to look great. But looking great doesn’t mean you have to stand behind a rope.” — Archie Gianunzio

His themes are never literal. The Peacock Room has a few photographs of peacocks and a wallpaper that suggests them, and the real reveal waits inside the closet. Archie calls these hidden gems: a detail that rewards the guest who notices it and stays out of the way of the guest who doesn’t.

“Nothing that I do is everywhere peacock, because to me that’s not design.” — Archie Gianunzio

He also designed the house to be photographed. His husband works in digital media, and Archie saw early how far a good picture travels. The aim was rooms people would want to post, and they do: friends like to tell him how often his wallpapers turn up in the background of other people’s photos.

“I made it look like a place that you’d want to photograph and be photographed in.” — Archie Gianunzio

Comfortable All the Time

Archie’s test for hospitality is a simple one: what would he want, and what would he need, if he were the guest. The first things the couple added were air conditioning and a heated pool. Every bedroom has a king bed. The kitchen carries what Archie keeps in his own: a KitchenAid mixer, an air fryer, piping bags and tips, because there is nowhere to order in. Every bedroom has sarongs, a beach blanket, beach bags, a steamer and an iron. Out back there is a bocce court with cornhole, and the couple did the landscaping themselves, down to the pink roses behind the court.

Bocce court beside the pool deck at 625 Shore Walk
The bocce and cornhole court out back, landscaped by Archie and Wesley.

Most rentals skip a stand mixer, because most guests never use one. Archie keeps one anyway. When he comes back after a group has left and finds his piping bags have been used, he is delighted.

“Everything you need to do whatever you want to do is there for you.” — Archie Gianunzio

“I don’t want you to have to want for anything. If you want someone to come back and stay at your house again and again, make it a place where they think, why would we go anywhere else?” — Archie Gianunzio

Heated pool on a wide cedar deck behind 625 Shore Walk

Archie still tries to go out between groups to check the beds himself, because he wants every group to walk into a house that feels cared for. Depending on who is arriving, there may be fresh cookies, a handle of vodka with a note from Archie and Wesley, or a welcome on the kitchen chalkboard with a returning group’s names, so they feel the house is theirs too. The point is the return visit: Archie would rather a week opened up only when a regular group gave it up. He wanted the house to be photographed, too. Along the catwalk, museum-quality lettering from WordsAnywhere.com reads “There’s no crying in the Pines,” borrowed from A League of Their Own. By Archie’s count, nine in ten groups take a picture of themselves in front of it, crying.

The thirteen-foot skylight above the catwalk at 625 Shore Walk, with the lettering There’s no crying in the Pines on the catwalk wall
The catwalk under the thirteen-foot skylight, and the most photographed wall in the house: nearly every group posts a picture in front of “There’s no crying in the Pines.”

The line is a joke, and it isn’t. Archie grew up not knowing a place like the Pines could exist, and the sign is his reminder to everyone who stays to enjoy every minute of being there.

“As a teenager, I never would have believed you if you told me that it could exist, or that I could live in a place where we’re allowed to be this. Look where you are. We shouldn’t be crying when we’re out here.” — Archie Gianunzio

The approach has worked. Groups come back summer after summer, and the house now rents by the week through the season, starting at $10,000 a week.

Pines Design

The house on Shore Walk turned into a practice. The couple bought a second house, redesigned it and sold it, and Archie has since been hired to do the same for three more. One was a six-bedroom house on the bay where guests kept saying it did not feel like Fire Island; the owners asked him to consult, then asked him to do the whole thing. In the couple’s own second house he went further, because no one was going to live there: a 1970s bedroom lined with mirrors became Alice Through the Looking-Glass, down to a top hat in one closet and a teacup in the bathroom. He is now taking an interior design certificate course, and he loves working on vacation rentals, where owners are often happy to be bolder than they would be at home. His favorite compliment now comes secondhand, when guests at Shore Walk say it reminds them of a house friends rented, and the house turns out to be one of his.

His best projects start with owners who already love the look of his houses: color, pattern and personality in every room.

“What I do is very colorful, pattern. More is more. I believe a place should feel like someone lives there.” — Archie Gianunzio

He works under the name Pines Design, an LGBTQ-owned design business based in New York that redesigns vacation rentals to be remembered and rebooked. Owners who want the same treatment for their own house can see his work and get in touch at pines-design.com.

Joy on a Slip of Land

He walks the boardwalks the old way, saying hello to everyone he passes, and he wants the houses he designs to feel the way the place does.

“I want it to be joyful out there because it should be, because that place represents the place we were always allowed to be ourselves and be joyful.” — Archie Gianunzio

Archie Gianunzio and Wesley Bonner in front of bougainvillea with the sea behind them
Archie Gianunzio and his husband, Wesley Bonner.
Boardwalk leading to the front of the cedar house on Shore Walk

Stay at 625 Shore Walk

625 Shore Walk has four bedrooms, each with a king bed, and rents by the week, Thursday to Wednesday. It is booked directly with Archie and Wesley through the house’s own site, fireislandpinesrental.com, with no platform in between. See the house on Locèlle.

Interview & editing
Justin Henry
|
Photography
courtesy of Archie Gianunzio and Wesley Bonner
Owners
Archie Gianunzio and Wesley Bonner
|
Interiors: Archie Gianunzio
Justin Henry
About the editor

Justin Henry is the founder and editor of Locèlle, telling the stories of design-led homes and the people who build them.

Read the letter from the founders

Own a home with a story of its own? Submit your home to Locèlle

For owners

Own a home like this? See what you could keep.

Airbnb and Vrbo take about 15% of every booking. Answer four quick questions and see what booking direct could be worth to you.

Try the calculator
Why Book This House

Seven Summer Days in the Pines

625 Shore Walk
625 Shore Walk
1429
View home