Phillipsport Church

Wurtsboro, NY
5
Bedroom
6
Guest
2
Bath

Wurtsboro, NY: a restored 19th‑century church retreat

Step inside a beautifully re‑imagined 1823 church retreat where history meets quiet luxury. Designed and restored by architect Matthew Bremer of Architecture in Formation, Phillipsport Church invites long weekends of slow mornings, lively dinners and lazy afternoons beside the fire orb, all wrapped in soaring, sun‑washed spaces that feel both sacred and welcoming.

The story of the space

Nearly two centuries old, this former rural church stood silent until Matt saw its potential: a timeless sanctuary just waiting to be lived in. With deep respect for its original simplicity, he preserved the expansive sanctuary’s light‑filled openness, original details and lofty proportions while layering in modern comfort and thoughtful design. What was once pews and pulpit is now curated living: a chef’s kitchen, a generous lounge, dining under soaring ceilings and plenty of room to gather.

Downstairs, the former basement, once the Sunday School and fellowship hall, is now serene sleeping quarters: quiet bedrooms tucked into the foundation’s gentle glow, a perfect counterpoint to the open sanctuary above.

Why Locèlle loves it

  • A true Catskills original. From its 1823 bones to its moments of modern whimsy, this isn’t just a stay. It’s a story you live in.
  • Sacred spaces made for gathering. The open sanctuary feels like home, perfect for reconnecting with friends, family, your partner or your own creative rhythm.
  • Quiet luxury with heart. Rustle‑free linens, a chef’s kitchen, sunlit gathering spaces and a fire‑lit lounge strike the balance between comfort and unforgettable moments.
  • Nature just outside your door. Quiet lanes, forested walks, and the nearby Catskills and Shawangunk Ridge make this retreat ideal for hikers, explorers and slow‑paced wanderers alike.

As seen in: Architectural Digest, The New York Times, New York Magazine, Curbed, and Scribner's Lodge Post.

Who it’s for

This is a home for those who want more than a place to sleep. It’s for people who cherish design with depth, history with intention, and stays that feel like visiting a dear friend’s most treasured getaway.

Photography by Michelle Rose

‍

From
$
545
/night
Book Direct
This host considers short-term leases but needs time to review your request. Send an inquiry to get started.
Book Direct with HostInquire and Book DirectMessage the Host
Why Stay Here

A sacred escape in the Catskills

A restored 19th-century church in the Catskills, full of character and calm. Made for slow mornings, long talks, and a true escape into nature.

Stay in a former 1823 chapel reimagined with warmth and intention: vaulted ceilings, original details and sunlit gathering spaces that feel both sacred and inviting.
Restored by architect Matthew Bremer of Architecture in Formation, with a chef’s kitchen and a fire-lit lounge beneath soaring ceilings.
Generous common spaces, quiet bedrooms and modern touches make group escapes with family, friends or creatives easy, comfortable and restorative.
Meet Your Hosts

Matt Bremer

Matthew Bremer is the founder of Architecture in Formation and the creative mind behind his 200-year-old Catskills church, transformed into a stunning home and unforgettable getaway. A native Texan with a Yale architecture background, Matt blends design, art and a New Yorker’s sensibility, curating spaces he loves to share, entertain in and explore. Between NYC, the Catskills and East Hampton, he’s hiking, traveling, sipping martinis and keeping his two Salukis, Noah and Moses, busy.
About the space

Every detail tells a story.

Discover how this home was designed, curated, and brought to life—inside and out.

Location

Where you’ll be

Wurtsboro

,

New York

,

United States

Neighborhood highlights

Nature & Adventure: Hike the Shawangunk Ridge and Catskills trails, explore forest paths, paddle local rivers, or chase waterfalls and hidden swimming holes just minutes from the church. Winter skiing, zip-lining, and horseback riding keep the adventure going year-round.

Local Charm & Culture: Discover Wurtsboro’s antique shops, cafés, and artisanal markets, or take a short drive to nearby Monticello, Bethel, and Liberty for farm-to-table dining, galleries, seasonal events, and the iconic Bethel Woods Center for the Performing Arts.

Why Book This House

Heritage Meets Restorative Escape

Phillipsport Church pairs historic architecture with thoughtful design and deep calm. Guests return for the space, the quiet, the fire-lit lounge and the surrounding nature. Restful nights, creative mornings and unhurried days await.

From the same host

More homes from this host

Homes featured in

Architectural Digest
The New York Times
Dwell
Magnolia Network
Condé Nast Traveler
ArchDaily
Country Living
Sunset
featured listings

Stay somewhere with a story

Every home books directly with its host. No platform fees.